Plan B, or the morning-after pill, has finally been approved by the FDA for over-the-counter sale, after a lot of political manuevering. However, there's a catch - women under 18 still need a doctor to prescribe this medicine. I guess teenage pregnancy and unwanted children are morally and socially better than birth control.
A spokesperson for the
Christian Medical Association, interviewed by the CBC for a story on Plan B, believes women wanted doctors who were moral, and who would make 'good health decisions'. So, a doctor would make a
health decision based on
morality, rather than his/her patient's health? Also, the spokesperson cited a survey where 79% of pharmicists felt that they should be able to refuse to prescribe drugs when deemed immoral. That doesn't say anything about the pharmacists' morals.
Why do these people believe that since they follow a certain set of morals, everyone should and wishes to follow these same morals? Can't they stick to patrolling themselves?
The CMA's Associate Executive Director, an obstetrician, claims
"The current packaging of these pills also violates the vital medical principle of informed consent. The FDA allows patient education material to claim that the product does not affect pregnancy or cause abortion. The drug's labeling falsely assures women that they are not taking the life of a human being when they take the pill. While some within the scientific community have obfuscated for political reasons the terms associated with early human development, a significant percentage of women still consider pregnancy to begin with fertilization. [...] Many women will feel betrayed when they learn the scientific realities of the mechanisms of action." (
CMA press release)
The CMA views Plan B as an aborticide; however, Plan B has no effect if a woman is already pregnant. How hyprocrital of the CMA.
An FDA official has admitted that the FDA was pressured by higher levels of the government to rescind their approval of the drug.
I can't help but think of the recent law that requires minors to have a parent or guardian accompany them out of state for an abortion. An opinion piece, in the
New York Times recently, made a good point:
most parents want to know where their daughters are, and want the best for their daughters, but not
all of them.
P.S. I will admit that the pro-Plan B interviewees were sometimes, I think, a bit too biased about their opponents. Surely the right-wing religious associations don't believe that sex is acceptable if it's solely for the sake of propagating the species? Oh, I forgot about
sodomy laws.
[/rant]